OBITUARY: Ian Lockie

Ian Lockie was born in Giffnock, Renfrewshire on 18 May 1936 and died in York on 24 March 2020, aged 83. He had been my friend for longer than anyone else having lived initially in Evan Drive, Giffnock not far from my home in Huntley Ave. We went together to Giffnock Primary School, then to Hutcheson’s Grammar School (“Hutchie”) before spending time at Glasgow University. Ian qualified with an MA degree and was successful in gaining a rare position as a Traffic Apprentice with British Railways after which he became Station Master at Stranraer. His responsibilities covered two stations and the ferry link to Larne in Northern Ireland. Later he moved to England being based at York in the offices there and later joined the team that examined the case for closure of a station or route. His last “for closure” line was the Settle and Carlisle route and he was sufficiently convinced that this should remain open that he took a deliberately long time to consider the situation so that by the time he produced the weakest possible case for closure the political climate had changed and closure moves were withdrawn. Today the “S&C” remains as a memorial to Ian busy with full passenger trains and heavy through freight traffic. He sent reports regularly to this writer for inclusion in the ERS Journal, and later in this news site.

In his time off duty Ian had an active musical life playing the cello with considerable skill in a York based orchestra. He had a major interest in Coastal Shipping, especially on the Clyde and every year he would make a point of “sailing doon the watter”. He was well known to the crew on the preserved paddler “Waverley”. He joined the Church of Scotland (with this writer) in Giffnock South Parish Church almost 70 years ago but found no difficulty becoming active within the Church of England taking services at his local church as a “reader”. Opposed to women serving in the clergy he faced stressful situations at times but eventually accepted the position that was agreed by the Archbishops. Ian never married but is survived by his brother David who had been a family doctor in Tighnabruaich before retiring to Tenerife.

A brief service was held at York Crematorium on 6 April 2020 but a celebration of his life will take place at a future date when the present gathering together restrictions are eased.

Iain Frew

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on OBITUARY: Ian Lockie

OBITUARY: Andrew Steel

Always known as Andy, he was born in Glasgow on 8 October 1946. His father was a tax inspector and moved about the country to the West Midlands and then Liverpool. Andy went to Glasgow University to study engineering and while working in York he met Jill whom he married in December 1973. For a time Andy worked in Kenya maintaining the trains but returned to the UK and was involved in an attempt to develop a European standard for light rail vehicles. He had a lively interest in history and how things could fit together. He was General Manager of Midland Metro, and then of the Manchester network. Although as a working engineer he was involved in the creation of new light railway systems, he also was greatly involved in the preservation of historic trams at the National Tramway Museum at Crich. He had two daughters, Kirsty (who died from cancer in her 20s), and Alex who has two children. Andy kept himself active, enjoying playing rugby in his earlier years, and very much enjoyed walking with friends. Holidays were usually quite adventurous with long trips to Kenya or Vietnam as examples. His death was unexpected. During the night of 2 November 2019 he experienced some chest pain and went downstairs to take something to deal with it. He was found the following morning sitting in his favourite chair – dead. The Coroner had to be involved and Andy was found to have sustained a major heart attack. Andy was a catalyst for many others whom he helped to develop their careers. Although “retired” for two years he was a regular attender at our West Midlands meetings and followed the almost completed extensions to the West Midlands network actively.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on OBITUARY: Andrew Steel

OBITUARY: Richard Hope OBE

One of the best known transport journalists, Richard Hope, died on 14 October 2019 at the age of 85. He worked for the “Railway Gazette International” for around 50 years (1964-2014) being Editor for twenty one years (1970 – 1991). He was interested in some of the news items that were on our site appearing there before he knew of them from his usual sources. He was awarded the OBE in 1991 for his work in railway journalism. However his connection with transport extended into the enthusiast field. He was secretary of the Talyllyn Railway Society for over 30 years, later becoming President of the Society.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on OBITUARY: Richard Hope OBE

The Woodhead Route

The Woodhead route provided a link between Sheffield and the Yorkshire coalfield with Manchester and latterly a power station near Widnes. Roughly midway between Sheffield and Manchester the railway plunged through the Pennines via the Woodhead Tunnels. There are three bores in all – the first two used by the Sheffield, Ashton-under Lyne, and Manchester Railway from its opening in 1845. This company combined with other local railways in 1847 to form the Manchester, Sheffield and Lincolnshire Railway, renamed the Great Central Railway in 1897. The 1923 amalgamations brought it into the LNER and later British Railways. Very heavy coal traffic and relatively heavy passenger traffic was carried from the early years and there were plans in 1936 to electrify the route but these were delayed by World War 2. Over time the old bores had degraded substantially and repairs would have been extremely costly so that the option to dig a single bore for the double track line became the obvious way ahead. The original bores had become seriously damaged by the powerful blast from the steam locomotives and the southern bore was deemed unrepairable.

When World War 2 was over work started on the construction of a single double track tunnel and this was completed in 1955 together with electrification of the route using the then “standard” power at 1500v DC from overhead wires. To operate the line two designs of locomotive were produced at Gorton Works, Manchester, The EM1 class (class 77) was produced to haul the heavy coal trains while the EM2 class 78 would handle the hourly express passenger services. Class 506 emus were produced for the Manchester (Piccadilly) Glossop – Hadfield suburban service.

Traffic was heavy for a good number of years but coal traffic began to fall and it was clear that this would cease in future years. An alternative route between Manchester and Sheffield via the Hope Valley was available and this would be difficult to close because it served several rather isolated villages. The fast passenger service was transferred to the Hope Valley line from 05-01-1970 and the remaining freight traffic soon followed. The Class EM1s were sold to the Netherlands Railways and served out a decent lifespan there. The EM2s needed a costly upgrade if they were to continue in use but this was rejected since it had been decided to convert the Manchester – Hadfield section to 25kV AC (the new standard system) with the Class 506 emus replaced initially by 303s from Glasgow and now by Class 323 emus. The line from Hadfield through the Tunnel was mothballed and in 2007 the tunnels were purchased by the National Grid to provide a route across the Pennines for major cables that was protected from severe weather conditions. This was achieved during the period 2008-12. Redundant track was lifted but much of the line east of the Tunnels remains in use by a daily Rotherham – Stockbridge freight service that serves a rather isolated steel plant.

Today one of the early Woodhead bores is felt to be in very fragile condition and will not be repaired. The other bores are used as a safe route for the cables. Proposals to use the tunnels for motor vehicle traffic as part of the Motorway network have been quietly dropped. There has been occasional mention of a possible suburban service at the Sheffield end but the population has not grown enough and the Sheffield station serving the Woodhead line is poorly located.

Iain Frew

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on The Woodhead Route

British Timetable Review May 2019


On 20 May 2018 took place the greatest change in the timetables of Britain’s railways at any one time in the 20+ years since privatisation. As readers will know, this did not go well because of ‘timetable melt down’ at both Govia Thameslink and at Northern. This led to a near complete freeze of changes for a year. Only in May 2019 has it been deemed practical to make further significant timetable changes including electrification in London, the West Midlands, the North-West and especially Scotland. The most extensive changes are again on Northern, Govia Thameslink and the electric services of London Northwestern / West Midlands Railway. Further deliveries of a large number of new types of trains will make timetabling quite volatile for the next 2 or 3 years at least.

c2c (emus)

On Saturdays and Sundays there is a new hourly train stopping only at Barking between Fenchurch Street and Benfleet. At the same time weekend trains from Fenchurch Street via Chafford Hundred which previously terminated at Southend Central continue to Shoeburyness.

Chiltern Railways (dmus and diesel loco-hauled)

Branch trains between Leamington Spa and Stratford-upon-Avon have mostly become extensions of trains from Marylebone to Banbury.

CrossCountry (dmus and HSTs)

On Mondays to Fridays three Manchester – Bristol Temple Meads trains are extended to Exeter St. Davids. 4 minutes has been added to the schedules of Nottingham – Birmingham – Cardiff trains for the future new station at Worcestershire Parkway.

East Midlands Trains (dmus and HSTs)

There are some shuffles of the timings of peak InterCity trains.

Great Western Railway (IETs, emus, dmus and diesel loco-hauled)

Great Western Railway (GWR) is preparing a largely new timetable from December 2019 to reflect electrification works from Didcot to Cardiff and to Chippenham. New hybrid IET trains already delivered have already replaced HSTs on express services from Paddington without change of timetable. In the meantime GWR have introduced one additional train from Cheltenham Spa to Paddington and back on Mondays to Fridays and added about 4 minutes to the schedules of most trains between Oxford and Worcester in anticipation of the opening of the new station at Worcestershire Parkway.

There are two changes in the West of England. After installation of extra signalling sections, on Mondays to Saturdays there are about half a dozen extra trains between Plymouth and Penzance filling in the gaps of the present irregular services. On the St. Ives branch the previous park and ride site at Lelant Saltings has been replaced by one at St. Erth. The halt at Lelant Saltings now has just a nominal service.

(Abellio) Greater Anglia (emus, dmus, and electric loco-hauled, plus possibly diesel)

Greater Anglia has ordered a completely new train fleet but none had entered service in time for the new timetable. On Mondays to Saturdays there are additional ‘Norwich in 90’ trains leaving Liverpool Street at 11 00 and 19 00 returning at 09 00 and 17 00. This has somewhat disrupted the pathing of other trains.

The timetable now reflects the temporary closure of the line between Reedham (Norfolk) and Great Yarmouth for engineering work. The few trains concerned now run via Acle. A new station in the Lea Valley at Meridian Water has replaced Angel Road. From September 2019 it will also be served by a half-hourly shuttle from Stratford all 7 days of the week. On Sundays the Liverpool Street – Southend Victoria trains which previously ran slow from Romford are now fast from Romford to Shenfield

London Northwestern / West Midlands Railway (emus, dmus and gas/flywheel)

In this timetable change the TOC has made widespread changes and improvements, mainly to electric services but diesel serves haven’t been forgotten. One important operational change was to link services north and south of Birmingham New Street on Mondays to Saturdays. The linkages aren’t symmetrical so one train per hour from Rugeley TV terminates at Birmingham International but returns to Liverpool. They offer through services from Euston, Watford Jn. and Milton Keynes to points beyond Birmingham such as Walsall, Wolverhampton and and Liverpool at fares often much cheaper than the faster express services of Virgin Trains.

Emu service via Stafford

The hourly service all 7 days from Euston via Nuneaton and other Trent Valley stations to Stafford, Stoke-on-Trent and Crewe is diverted to run direct between Stafford and Crewe. On Sundays this service used to run via Northampton as well but now runs direct except on Sunday mornings. An alternative service for Stoke-on-Trent runs hourly from Birmingham via Wolverhampton, Stafford and Stoke-on-Trent to Crewe with trains originating south of Birmingham on Mondays to Saturdays.

Emu service Euston to Milton Keynes, Northampton, Coventry and Birmingham

This is changed in detail with some extra peak short workings from Euston. On Sundays there is an extra hourly service from Euston to Birmingham via Northampton; south of Rugby this replaces the Euston – Crewe via Trent Valley service now running direct to Rugby.

Walsall and Cross-City

Walsall to Rugeley Trent Valley has been electrified but with little change of train service. Half of Cross-City emu services except evenings and Sundays used to terminate at Lichfield City; they now continue to Lichfield Trent Valley. The half-hourly evening service north of Birmingham to Lichfield has been increased to 4 trains per hour on Mondays to Fridays to Lichfield City and on Saturdays to Four Oaks.

Dmu services

There are various improvements to peak services through Birmingham Snow Hill. On Monday to Saturday evenings frequencies have been improved to very approximately half-hourly to Kidderminster, Whitlocks End and Dorridge. Between Wolverhampton and Shrewsbury there are 2 changes. On Mondays to Saturdays there is a new hourly daytime semi-fast service from Birmingham New Street to Shrewsbury. On Sundays this TOC has replaced the 2-hourly TfW service local service between Wolverhampton and Shrewsbury by an hourly service through from Birmingham New Street. Further south, on Mondays to Saturdays the services from Coventry to Nuneaton on one side and to Kenilworth and Leamington Spa on the other are linked into a through hourly service from Nuneaton to Leamington Spa.

London Overground (emus)

The timetable shows that the 7 days stopping service between Euston and Watford Jn. has been increased to quarter-hourly. In practice it is now 3 trains per hour very unevenly spaced. Because of delays in implementing new emus, the 7 days quarter-hourly service between Gospel Oak and Barking was only running half-hourly with extras at the beginning of the timetable period.

LNER (‘Azumas’, electric loco-hauled and HSTs)

Probably from 9 September the Monday to Saturday 2-hourly short working trains from Kings Cross to Newark Northgate are extended to Lincoln.

Northern (emus and dmus)

Northern continues to add services as transfer of additional units from other TOCs and electrification between Manchester, Bolton and Preston make possible.

Broadly east of the Pennines (diesel unless stated)

On Mondays to Saturdays most trains from Lincoln to Sheffield (on to Leeds) now run fast Worksop to Sheffield. The stops between are covered by an extra hourly shuttle Gainsborough Central – Sheffield

The following changes apply on Mondays to Saturdays. The gaps in the York via Selby to Hull service have been filled. The Sheffield – York direct service increased from 2 to 3 trains per day. There is an extra hourly off-peak semi-fast between Leeds and Harrogate, while the Huddersfield – Wakefield Kirkgate service is extended to Castleford. On Sundays the Leeds – ‘Dearne’ – Sheffield and the electric Leeds – Doncaster services increased form 2-hourly to hourly. There is an extra hourly Leeds – York stopping service enabling the Blackpool – York services to omit some intermediate stops.

On Mondays to Saturdays the half-hourly service from Hull to Bridlington continues to Scarborough hourly rather than every 1½ hours. On Sundays the hourly service to Bridlington continuing 2-hourly to Scarborough now runs through hourly. On Mondays to Saturdays there is an additional semi-fast from Newcastle to Carlisle operated as an extension of the Morpeth to Newcastle shuttle. Further south the service from Skipton to Lancaster and Morecambe is improved with changes in the ‘triangulation’ between Lancaster, Morecambe and Carnforth.

The North West (emus and dmus)

Electrification between Manchester, Bolton and Preston has enabled services to be rationalised, but presumably because of constraints of resources (human or rolling stock?), the new timetable only took full effect on 1 July. Northern’s new hourly service pattern between Manchester and Preston on Mondays to Saturdays is as follows:

Manchester Airport via Wigan to Preston and Lancaster, then 2 in 3 to Barrow-in-Furness and 1 in 3 to Windermere. The gap in hourly service between Lancaster and Barrow is filled by a train from Lancaster via Barrow and the Cumbrian Coast to Carlisle. These trains are diesel at least at present.

Manchester Airport via Bolton to Blackpool North skipping a few stops.

Hazel Grove via Bolton to Blackpool North skipping a few different stops.

Manchester Victoria to Preston all stations from Bolton.

Trains have barely been accelerated. In addition in the off-peak the Manchester Victoria – Bolton – Wigan Wallgate – Kirkby service has been split in two at Wigan Wallgate. Sunday services now follow a similar pattern without the Hazel Grove – Blackpool North train but the Manchester Victoria – Preston stopping train continuing to Blackpool North.

Other changes on Mondays to Saturdays are the re-extension of York – Preston services to Blackpool North, while one Leeds – Bradford Interchange – Manchester Victoria service continues hourly fast to Warrington Bank Quay and Chester. No doubt due to human resource constraints 3 hourly services have been withdrawn for the summer resuming in mid-September:

Manchester Piccadilly – Hazel Grove

Liverpool Lime Street – Wigan North Western

Manchester Victoria – Wigan Wallgate

ScotRail (HSTs, emus, dmus and diesel loco-hauled)

Under the EGIP (Edinburgh Glasgow Improvement Programme) a number of lines have been electrified and with new trains services have been accelerated but without increases in service frequency, for example:

Edinburgh to Glasgow Queen Street High Level via Falkirk High

Edinburgh to Dunblane and Glasgow Queen Street High Level to Alloa in both cases via Sirling

Kirknewton via Shotts to Holytown for service from Edinburgh to Glasgow Central. However trains on this route still observe diesel timings

Frequency improvements can be expected when work at Glasgow Queen Street High Level is completed in 2020. Continued disruptive engineering works are in progress on the route from Aberdeen to Elgin and Inverness for completion in time for the December 2019 timetable change.

South Western Railway (emus and dmus)

South Western Railway took over the franchise from South West Trains in August 2017 with a commitment to making extensive changes. Most previously promised off-peak changes are unlikely to be implemented, but in May 2019 a number of improvements took place mainly to peak and shoulder-peak services. These particularly apply from Waterloo to the Portsmouth Direct line, towards Southampton and Bournemouth and in the suburban / outer suburban area of the Windsor Lines.

There are 2 sets of all-day changes to electric services. Almost all Portsmouth Direct express services join their equivalents on Sundays by calling at Godalming. On Mondays to Saturdays the Ascot – Aldershot – Guildford shuttle service is divided into 2 services. The trains from Ascot now terminate at Aldershot to connect into a new Guildford – Aldershot – Farnham shuttle. Finally for electric services, the Portsmouth Direct line has 3 extra Sunday fasts each way at 16 26, 17 26 and 18 26 from Portsmouth & Southsea to Waterloo and return, plus a single 18 10 from Poole to Waterloo restoring a 100-minute schedule from Bournemouth to Waterloo (a journey time customary when the line was electrified 50 years ago).

There are a large number of improvements to diesel services based at Salisbury. East of Salisbury the service from Waterloo on Monday to Saturday evenings increases to half-hourly. On Sundays there is an extra hourly service from Salisbury to Basingstoke and Reading from 07 52 to 15 52 for connections to Waterloo. West of Salisbury towards Yeovil Jn. there are two daytime ‘infill’ services on Mondays to Fridays to Yeovil Jn. and on Sundays two to Gillingham. There are various complex additions all days of the week on the services through from Waterloo via Salisbury to Westbury and variously on to Bristol Temple Meads, Frome, Castle Cary and Yeovil Pen Mill. There are now sufficient trains to make practical day trips from these stations to Waterloo.

TfL Rail (emus)

On Sundays the half-hourly short workings from Liverpool Street to Gidea Park continue to Shenfield as with the rest of the service. The Monday to Saturday TfL Rail half-hourly service from Paddington to Hayes & Harlington now runs on Sundays as well but not after mid-evening.

(Govia) Thameslink Railway (emus), Southern (emus and dmus) and Great Northern (emus)

Great Northern

On Mondays to Fridays with a few night exceptions, Hertford Loop trains have been withdrawn between Watton-at-Stone and Stevenage for engineering work at Stevenage.


The process of ‘filling out’ Thameslink services continues with the following additions to the hourly pattern through the ‘core’ between St. Pancras International and Blackfriars:

Mondays to Fridays
Up from 15 to 16 trains per hour with the Cambridge – Brighton service up to half-hourly.

Up from 7 to 11 trains per hour:

Extra Cambridge – Brighton hourly

Extra Bedford – Gatwick Airport half-hourly

Kentish Town – Rainham up to half-hourly

Up from 5 to 11 trains per hour:

Extra Cambridge – Gatwick Airport hourly (previously to Kings Cross)

Extra Bedford – Gatwick Airport hourly

Extra Bedford – Three Bridges hourly

Kentish Town – Rainham up to half-hourly

Luton – anti-clockwise via Sutton to Blackfriars extended to Luton

Blackfriars – clockwise via Sutton to Luton now extended from St. Albans but terminates at St. Albans. The oddity of the last 2 entries is that anti-clockwise trains run Luton to Luton but clockwise St. Albans to St. Albans

(First) TransPennine Express (emus and dmus)

Manchester to Edinburgh / Glasgow services via Carlisle serve Manchester Oxford Road again. From 9 September TPE will be running what is in principle a new 4-hourly service between Liverpool Lime Street and Glasgow Central 7 days. Intermediate stopping patterns and routing especially at both ends of the route are somewhat irregular. In various tables extensions are shown of a few trains north of Newcastle to Edinburgh. None are shown in operator publicity and have yet to start.

Transport for Wales (dmus and diesel loco-hauled)

A new service generally hourly has started between Liverpool Lime Street, Runcorn and Chester with odd extensions to Wrexham General.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on British Timetable Review May 2019

Stadler Trams and Trains

The tram and train manufacturer, Stadler, has appeared many times in our news reports as the supplier of a new batch of stock for light railways in many locations across the world. The company has its headquarters in the Swiss town of Bussnang, in Thurgau Canton in the far north of Switzerland. The town has a population of a little over 2,000 and therefore cannot be the location of the factories in which its wide range of light rail, tram:train, and heavy rail multiple units are built. In fact Stadler has factories or assembly plants in many locations across the world and with an eye for business production facilities are opened up in countries where new metros or light railways are planned. In mid 2019 such factories exist in Poland, Hungary, Belarus, and Spain. The company took over a factory complex in Valencia, Spain, and vehicles for the UK are being assembled there. In India, where smog is an increasing dangerous problem, new Metros are to be built in the cities of Amaravat and Visakhapatnam, and anticipating possible orders for trains for one or both of these new metros Stadler is planning to built an assembly plant in Andhra Pradesh. This will be well placed to handle orders from the Indian sub-continent and nations across the Pacific. A plant in the USA is being considered to meet that nation’s requirement that a large proportion of manufactured items must include local content.

Stadler exhibited at the recent Railtex exhibition in the NEC in Solihull, West Midlands. There were three categories of vehicle about which there was information being displayed at their stand – different types of Low Floor LRV – Citylink tram:trains – and various types of emu for use on suburban railway networks or on new Metro lines. The company has produced attractive leaflets describing each of these vehicles with information about orders from specific customers.

Leaflets gave information about three models of low-floor LRV produced by the company. In 2013 Stern and Hafferl, the Austrian light railway operator, ordered eleven metre gauge five-segment LRVs for use in the city of Gmunden. In many respects these trams are similar to the six standard gauge five-section LRVs ordered for the Croydon Tramlink network in 2011 with repeat orders for four LRVs in 2013, and two more in 2015. Both have a stainless steel body, with four doors on each side, 75 and 72 seats respectively, and standing room for 100 or 134 respectively. The higher number of standing passengers in the Croydon LRVs reflects the slightly wider bodies of the standard gauge LRVs compared with the metre gauge Gmunden vehicles. Both types take power at 750 V DC while the top operating speed is 70km/hour (Gmunden) or 80km/hour (Croydon).

A third type of Low-floor LRV was included in the leaflets – the seven-section LRVs of which nine were ordered in January 2018 for use in Lugano, Switzerland. In many respects these metre gauge LRVs which will be delivered from the Valencia factory in 2020, are similar to the Croydon trams. The stainless steel bodies will have 70 seats and standing space for 228 passengers. Power will be taken at 1200 V DC through a pantograph. These long LRVs will be carried on four bogies and there will be 8 double doors on each side to ensure rapid loading and unloading at stops.

Three types of tram:train were highlighted on the Railtex stand. The oldest version was the Citylink tram for use on the commuter rail network around Chemnitz in Germany, eight being ordered in August 2012, with a further four ordered in July 2015. These standard gauge three section trams operate on power at 750 V DC taken via a pantograph, with diesel-electric power pack
for operation on non-electrified branches. These tram:trains have 87 seats and have standing room for 141. They can attain a top speed of 100 km/hour.

Although tram:trains have operated on various systems in Europe, the UK’s first venture into the type of vehicle is in Sheffield. The South Yorkshire PTE ordered seven tram:trains in June 2013 with delivery in 2017. They were to provide vehicles that could operate over BR metals through Rotherham and onwards to a new shopping centre, and also to add a little to the overstretched fleet on the exiting Supertram network. They can take power through a pantograph at 750 V DC on the existing Supertram network, or at 25kV AC when on British Railways tracks. A top speed of 100 km/hour can be attained. These vehicles provide 96 seats with standing room for 140. The bodies are made with stainless steel and sadly two of these tram:trains have been involved in significant accidents. One has sustained severe damage and has had to be returned to the manufacturer where repairs may be possible. The other was less badly damaged and will be repaired locally.

The third type of tram:train lies in the future. The Wales and Borders franchise to operate heavy rail services throughout Wales was awarded in 2018 to the Keolis Amey Wales consortium which has decided to invest heavily in local rail services. They have ordered 36 three segment Citylink tram:trains and also 35 “Flirt” trains. The tram:trains will operate on 25 kV AC as well as battery power enabling which will avoid the need for providing costly overhead power wire equipment on quieter sections of the routes. The tram:trains will have the usual stainless steel bodies, will seat 130, and provide standing room for 256 passengers. There will be three double doors on each side of the tram:train and hopefully this will be sufficient when a service is filled to maximum capacity. The top speed for these tram:trains is 100 km/hour. These vehicles will take over services along the South Wales Valleys and will transform the level and style of service that exists at present.

There remains for consideration multiple units for use on standard gauge suburban railways, and one oddity – a medium gauge underground railway with an extremely restricted tunnel diameter.
First let us look at the WINK multiple units ordered by the Netherlands Railways. The eighteen two-car trains are designed for this era when there is concern for the future of the planet and when pollution is something that we are starting to realise is damaging the fabric of our world. These trains will operate at 1500 V DC taken from an overhead wire, or from engines powered by diesel fuel or by hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO). There is a longer term plan to replace these diesel or HVO powered engines by batteries to make the WINK units zero emission trains. They are likely to be introduced into service in 2020 and will seat 135 (151 if tip-up seats are included) people. They will reach a speed of 140 km/hour and there will be three wide doors on each side.

The largest order received by Stadler in recent years – for 52 four car emus was received in February 2017 from Merseytravel to replace the entire fleet operating of Liverpool’s Northern Line and between Liverpool and destinations in the Wirral. These services are among the best performing local services in the UK with high levels of customer satisfaction but the trains are now elderly and new trains are the only sensible answer. Platforms throughout the network are a standard height so these low floor emus are able to achieve level boarding for passengers. The trains will be able to be retrofitted for ERTMS and for handling a power supply at 25 kV AC when appropriate. At present power at 750 V DC is taken from a third rail. They will have batteries to allow movement in depots etc where there is no third rail. The new trains are expected to enter service during 2019-20 and each train will seat 182 people, plus 8 tip-up seats. They will have a top speed of 120 km/hour. These new trains will transform travel on what has been a group of lines that has always achieved high standards.

Now what is the odd sounding last in our list of current Stadler contracts? It is a line well known to myself – the 4’0” gauge Glasgow Subway that follows a roughly circular course between the city centre and inner suburbs to the west of the city. The tunnels are small in diameter so careful planning was necessary to produce a train that would fit in the tunnels and which would provide space inside the coaches for a tallish passenger. Originally the first trains were hauled around the route by gripping a moving cable but the route was later electrified using tramcar motors. The original stock was eventually replaced by the present fleet and the time has come for a third fleet to take over services on what is the third oldest underground railway in the world. Seventeen Metro trains have been ordered and each comprises two half-trains coupled together to form what looks like a four car train, the outer coaches being somewhat longer than the two middle coaches. Each complete train will have 104 seats plus 8 tip-up seats, and space for 199 standees. It must be stressed that all the train/LRV types detailed so far have assumed that standing passengers will be 4 per square metre. On the Glasgow Subway, on which travel times will be very short, the number quoted is on the basis of 6 standees per square metre. Watch out! Co-ordinate your breathing! More seriously, there will be a powerful ventilation system. The complete train will have four coaches so that the complete train can negotiate the relatively sharp curves along the route. A three coach train, as with the present fleet, would have longer coaches which would have to be slightly narrower to fit along the route. There will be six double doors per train side to allow rapid loading and unloading.

The Subway had a charmed life in the later part of the 20th century with the tunnel walls crumbling and all the equipment on the trains and at the Govan Depot out of date. Many of the suburbs on the south side of the city had seen a sharp decline in population and whole areas had seen the demolition of virtually all of the buildings. Govan Parish Church, a truly historic ancient building, stood alone with all other nearby buildings swept away. Today new building has brought people back to these areas and the Subway is proving to be the pollution-free way to travel. The new trains should be introduced during 2020 and will have a top speed of 58 km/hour although there will not be many places where this can be achieved.

Iain Frew

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Stadler Trams and Trains


The annual exchange of greetings cards over Christmastide has one sad but none-the-less helpful result. This is when relatives get in touch to inform the sender that unfortunately the intended recipient had passed away during the previous months. I received a card from Alex’s daughter Fiona just before Christmas telling me that Alex had died suddenly at home on 25 February 2018 and that his wife Margaret had had a severe stroke on the following day. Alex was a good friend and co-worker during the late 1950s and early 1960s when I was undertaking a piece of research. He was the head technician in the laboratory complex in Glasgow where I worked. But he was more than a brilliant technician – he was an expert in the operation of the network of railways around Glasgow (he lived in Kirkhill) and also of the Clyde steamer fleet that used to take Glaswegians “doon the watter” to the many resorts sprinkled along the Clyde estuary. Alex was a good photographer and many of the Clyde steamer views in this Society’s “Electrail Slides” range are from shots taken by Alex. Alex and Fiona visited the Society’s stand at Model Rail Scotland most years and was pleased to see that copies of his slides were still a draw for many customers.
Iain Frew, December 2018

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on OBITUARY: Alex Kerr

London Underground Route Diagrams

A large number of route maps of the LUL network exist, some produced by LUL itself and others by commercial firms wanting to show where their premises are in relation to LUL stations. In addition to the conventional diagrammatic route map there is now a similar map with highlighted sections that are in tunnels. This is designed to help passengers who are frightened of being in a confined space to find a more comfortable route. An extremely helpful map highlights stations that have a public toilet in the station or very close by, and this could be very useful if the passenger has made use of the map showing stations that include a coffee shop in or adjacent to the station.
There are maps showing how long it takes to get between stations on foot, on a bike, and using a scooter. Another map shows the location of the major theatres and their proximity to stations. A similar map shows where the small theatres or meeting venues are located. For those who feel hungry at unsocial hours McDonald’s have produced a map to show the location of those restaurants that are open until midnight, or throughout the whole 24 hours. A geographically correct map has been produced in which the various lines are so crowded together in the central areas that it is virtually impossible to identify all the stations – hence the reason for the usual diagrammatic map in which a useful amount of space has been created for downtown areas.. A fashion orientated map has been produced and shows altered station names such as Picca-Twiggy Circus with some connections with the fashion industry. A similar map showing a Shakespeare theme has been produced jointly by the Globe Theatre and TfL. Each Christmas TfL produces a map highlighting the location of festive attractions.

Iain Frew

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on London Underground Route Diagrams

British Timetable Review – December 2016

by Alan de Burton

Overview and Timetable Format

Unless otherwise specified, the text refers to Monday to Saturday timetables. This is very much a ‘marking time’ timetable before major changes in many parts of the country later in 2017 based on either new trains or infrastructure improvements. The main landmark this time has been the extension by Chiltern Trains of their service from Marylebone to Oxford Parkway on to Oxford.

C2c (emus)

C2c’s ‘start again’ timetable in December 2015 hadn’t worked well on Monday to Friday peaks and has been subject to frequent changes. In January 2017 they implemented another version this time bolstered by some extra rolling stock.

Cross Country (dmus and a few HSTs)

Completion of the flyover at Norton Bridge north of Stafford has enabled acceleration of trains from Bournemouth to Manchester by about 10 minutes.

Great Western (HSTs, dmus and diesel loco-hauled sleepers)

From September 2016, a few peak dmu services between Paddington and Greenford were diverted to Hayes & Harlington as emus and replaced by shuttles between West Ealing and Greenford. This arrangement now applies for the full working day.

Merseyrail (all emus)

Although not shown in the published timetable, engineering works are interrupting Wirral Line services under the Mersey between January and June 2017. At some periods trains are terminating at Birkenhead Central or North, at other times only the Loop under Liverpool is closed and trains are terminating at James Street.

ScotRail (emus, dmus and diesel loco-hauled)

The new station at Edinburgh Gateway has opened. On Mondays to Saturdays, half the trains that used to call at South Gyle now call here instead. However, the hourly faster trains from Edinburgh to Perth and to Dundee now call as well. The only other improvements of note are the through early morning trains on the Highland Main Line at 05 08 from Perth to Inverness and at 05 36 from Inverness to Edinburgh.

South West Trains (emus and dmus)

In December 2016 there were further improvements to the additional diesel services west of Salisbury which commenced in December 2015. Notable is a new Sunday train at 18 04 from Frome to Waterloo as an extension of a train previously starting at Salisbury. There are various other minor improvements.

TransPennine Express (dmus and emus)

The present hourly service 7 days between York and Newcastle has been supplemented by an extra train every 2 hours all 7 days, although on Mondays to Fridays there are some gaps. Pathing difficulties impose some curious stopping patterns, and most of the extra trains on Mondays to Saturdays run northbound non-stop from York to Durham.

Virgin Trains East Coast (electric loco-hauled and diesel HST)

This time there are some extra off-interval trains on Saturdays and Sundays between Kings Cross and mainly Leeds.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on British Timetable Review – December 2016

Farewell to Friends

Two good friends of the Society died recently and this note acknowledges the help that they gave over many years.
Brian Martin Longworth was born in Toronto to Scottish parents but soon the family returned to Scotland and Brian spent the rest of his life in the Glasgow area.    He worked for Glasgow Corporation’s Transport Department at the Bath Street headquarters and came to know just about everything about the extensive tramway network, and in more recent years about the complex suburban railway network.    Much of the Scottish news in our Journal came indirectly from Brian.    He died on 24 September 2016 – just 8 hours short of his 73rd birthday – from a brain tumour.   He had no living relatives and regarded the enthusiast railway and tramway bodies as his family.    Well over 100 attended his funeral on 06 October 2016 and at least six ERS members were present.   Many of those present had attended Glasgow’s Hutcheson’s Grammar School, including Brian, so that the reception at times became almost a school FP gathering complete with the singing of the school song!

Ernest Walker was born in Wiesbaden, Germany, where his father had been born and brought up but he moved to a job in Glasgow so that Ernie attended Hutcheson’s Grammar School then Glasgow University where he studied mathematics and accountancy.     He moved to the Toronto area soon after the completion of his studies becoming a prominent accountant in the Barrie area, moving to Waterloo after retirement.    Ernie was the source of much of the Canadian news material that appeared in the Journal over a period of over 40 years.    His funeral service was held in a Presbyterian Church in Waterloo and was conducted by his daughter Leslie, until recently one of a team of ministers at the Scots Kirk in Calgary.
Iain Frew.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Farewell to Friends